Interesting Song Cover Versions
Original Published Date : 2020-04-04
Some random cover versions that have popped up on my musical radar over the years.
Money (Thatâs What I Want)¶
This is the âoriginalâ version I grew up with from The Beatles. From 1963. Yes, Iâm aware they didnât write it, so this is in fact a cover. But it is by far the most well known version.
In 1979, John Lennon â who did the searing lead vocal on the above â was still with us. AFAIK his reaction to this cover-of-their-cover , went unrecorded đ This is âexperimental bandâ The Flying Lizards (whatâs with the floating at about the 1:14 mark ? StrangeâŚbut yet it fits in; that bit reminds me of a Twin Peaks sequence):
Summertime¶
So, Iâm a huge fan of George Gershwinâs music and also Peter Gabriel ; but never thinking the two would come together. And yet, they did. And boy was I happy.
There are many versions of the original song, from Gershwinâs 1935 opera Porgy and Bess. For my âoriginalâ Iâve picked what I believe is one with Billie Holiday on lead vocals:
And from 1994âs Glory of Gershwin tribute album, hereâs Peter Gabriel. The album is fantastic; it was also paying tribute to Larry Adler, the superb harmonica player, who had turned 80 and was on the album..as you can hear:
Alison¶
Probably the first allegedly controversial one in this list. So it goes like this. In 1977 Elvis Costello released his achingly bitter-sweet masterpiece Alison.
The following year Linda Ronstadt released her cover version of it:
The controversy is the conflicting stories that Elvis liked or disliked her version. I initially heard the dislike story, back in the 80s. But then since then people have said he liked it. Iâm not fussed either way.
It has caused a (still open?) discussion: if you pay the royalties/usage-rights can you cover a song, even if the original artist doesnât want you to?
All By Myself¶
Weâll do this one backwards, with the original second. Plus itâs only sort of a cover, as youâll see.
In 1975 Eric Carmen had a big hit with All By Myself. He had been playing music since he was a child and was very aware of classical music. As for this song, the âverse is based on the second movement (Adagio sostenuto) of Sergei Rachmaninoffâs Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, Opus 18âł (source: Wikipedia)
The Wikipedia article goes on âRachmaninoffâs music was in the public domain in the United States at that time and so Carmen thought no copyright existed on it, but it was still protected outside the U.S. Subsequent to the release of the album, he was contacted by the Rachmaninoff estate and informed that it was protected. An agreement was reached in which the estate would receive 12 percent of the royalties from âAll by Myselfâ as well as from âNever Gonna Fall in Love Againâ, which was based on the third movement from Rachmaninoffâs Symphony No. 2.â
Jump to about 12:20 in this clip: