Hanging Rock and Me
Original Published Date : 2020-05-11
A few items to do with my interactions with the location and film Picnic at Hanging Rock. No other place â nor movie â has quite the hold on me. I only live about one hour's drive from The Rock.

Note the vertical pillars of rock, they look like columns.
My baffling theory¶
When I was young, some musical people â guitarists, drummers, producers etc. â would put old egg cartons up on their walls. It would dampen the sound from bouncing back at them. And probably help prevent the sound from escaping into the neighbours' ears!

These days it is the more high-tech acoustic foam acting as the baffle:

I understand the sound comes into the gaps â in the baffle â and bounces around at all sorts of angles. Almost none of it leaves the foam block. The effect is that the sound is absorbed.
So...have a look again at that first photo of Hanging Rock. The rock columns. I think these pillars act a bit like the baffles. They might scatter and thus (appear to) absorb sound.
Maybe that is one of the reasons people â like me â say the place is 'weird' and 'strange'.
Three Mysterious Visits by Me¶
1. Upset tough kids on the bus¶
It was a relatively short gap between the book (1967) and film (1975). But in that gap my first mysterious visit to Hanging Rock took place. I hadnât read the book, but there were rumours of three girls having gone missing on the Rock.
Around 1974 or early 75 (before the film) we went on a school bus trip there. I was 13 or 14. All was going well, but then â as we were walking back to the bus â I could hear the commotion.
Some of the âschool toughsâ had been exploring the Rock â like all of us â and claimed to have seen three skulls in one of the many deep crevices. They were actually crying.
2. Lost in silence in a crowd¶
The family went up there again, a few years later. Maybe 1978, so after the film. I am the eldest child and got the OK to take a younger brother up to explore this mysterious place. It was warm and there were lots of people around.
We were up the top and somehow, which I still canât explain, everything went quiet. There appeared to be no sound. We could talk to each other, but there were no ambient sounds. There were also no other people nearby.
It was probably only 15 minutes, but we wandered around, quite lost. It was notorious for not having many signs, but I somehow found a track back down and all ended up being ok. My theory is that in the narrow crevices, the rocks somehow absorb â or reflect away â the external sounds.
3. Mist flowing up and not just Miranda lost¶
In 2nd year University (1980) my College â Roberts Hall â had a bus trip there in the cooler months. I had my film camera. We were up the top on a chilly day, when something Iâve never seen before (or since) happened.
Mist or fog rolled in from the plains, got pushed up the steep side of the Rock and flowed up-and-over the edge towards us on the top. I had black and white film in the camera and snapped off multiple shots.
A few days later I took the film in to the Universityâs photo processing place, who sent it off site.
And somehow, someone lost it. Never to be seen again.
The Typewriter¶
Joan Lindsay wrote the fictional book in 1967. It apparently came to her quickly and in a series of dreams and she would get up and write it all down. This was done at their lovely house Mulberry Hill at Langwarrin South in Victoria. Itâs not far from Mt Eliza on the Peninsula. We went there in 2017 and hereâs a photo I took:
The very typewriter she used to write the book is still there, in-situ:
She wasnât very tall and apparently it really was used on this low table.
Itâs Fiction, butâŚMARI and P.A. and⌶
In the mid 1970s a group of my teachers were interested in âwas it true?â. They went off to the State Library of Victoria to research. And found nothing to verify. No news reports, nothing about the school, the girls, the police. Zero.
The first clue is that she gives an exact date at the very start of the book: Saturday Feb 14th 1900. But that date wasnât a Saturday. Was she having fun or placing red-herrings via being so precise, yet âwrongâ?
Anyway, whole books have been written on âis is true?â. This is one summary.
However my teachers did spot something interesting which stuck in my mind.
Philip Adams, who knew Joan, has been interested in the mystery for years. In 2010, I emailed him asking about what the teachers had found:
âI wonder if itâs anything to do with the observation that the 3 missing girls all had the same first 4 initials in their first names: MARI ? [Marion, Irma, Miranda] Back in the 70âs a teacher pointed that out to us. Plus a 4th combination [is] RIMA. Meaning hole or fissure. Possible literary joke?â
He quickly got back to me:
ânope David , naught to do with itâŚ.will tell the whole story one dayâŚthe secret lies in A. a visit by two literary ladies to Versailles in 1901 B, .St,Valentineâs Day C. an old painting in the NGV D. Joan Lâs problems with clocksâŚâŚ and E, the probability that her brother-in-law, Norman Lindsay, was gay..â
He was true to his word and discussed this on an ABC RN Podcast in 2011. The ABC archives from back them seem to have links that go nowhere â i.e. get the 404 Not Found â so canât find the audio. Will email them to see if they have it.